Plant-Based vs Marine Collagen Serums: What the Label Really Means
'Vegan collagen' sounds like a neat solution. The label tells a more interesting story, and knowing how to read it is the most useful skincare skill you can pick up this year.
The Beauty Desk · Skincare · 5 minute read
The serum in this story
ANUA PDRN Hyaluronic Acid Capsule 100 Serum · $45.00
PDRN, hyaluronic acid and hydrolyzed collagen. Check the label if you have a fish allergy.
Which one is vegan?
Sophie, 41, a Hobart nurse, came to us with a single question: 'I want a natural collagen serum. Which one is vegan?' It sounds simple. It is one of the most misunderstood questions in skincare.
Plants do not make collagen. A 'plant collagen' serum contains plant extracts, not collagen.
Sophie and the other people in this piece are composite characters, not customer reviews. General cosmetic information only, not medical advice.
The first surprise: plants don't make collagen
Collagen is a protein made by animals. Plants do not make it. So a 'plant collagen' or 'vegan collagen' serum does not contain collagen. It contains plant extracts, amino acids or sugars marketed as plant-based alternatives, such as rice, soy or baobab. They can be pleasant, hydrating ingredients. They are simply not collagen, and the label should not suggest they are.
Reading the label
| On the label | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| Plant or vegan collagen | Plant extracts or amino acids, not collagen. |
| Marine or animal collagen | Often from fish skin or scales, broken into small hydrolyzed pieces. Check if you have a fish or shellfish allergy. |
| PDRN | Polydeoxyribonucleotide, a popular K-beauty ingredient commonly derived from salmon. In a cosmetic serum it is a hydrating, comfortable ingredient, not a treatment. |
How to choose
- Vegan or cruelty-free? Look for products that say so, and read the full ingredient list.
- Fish allergy? Avoid marine collagen and salmon-derived PDRN, or ask your pharmacist.
- Sensitive skin? Patch test first.
- Want simplicity? One hydrating serum you will actually use beats a shelf you won't.
Sophie's choice
Sophie chose a hydrating serum with hyaluronic acid and PDRN after checking the label for fish allergies, and keeps a plant-based hydrating mist for summer. 'Both feel nice,' she says. 'I stopped asking which one is a miracle.'
Editor's tip: claims to read with care.
If a label says plant collagen 'repairs' or 'rebuilds' skin, be careful. Cosmetic claims in Australia must not be misleading, and the ACCC watches this closely. For a calm look at what these serums can do, see do collagen serums work?
Around Australia
Hobart, Canberra and Melbourne: hydrating serums for dry winters. Sydney, Brisbane and Darwin: lightweight gels. Perth and Adelaide: serum, moisturiser and SPF. The same ingredient question comes up with eye patches; our piece on collagen vs PDRN eye patches untangles it.
Why start with the ANUA PDRN Hyaluronic Acid Capsule 100 Serum
Read the ingredient list before the marketing. If you want a hydrating place to start, this one brings PDRN, hyaluronic acid and hydrolyzed collagen together, at $45.00 at the time of writing. Check the label if you have a fish allergy.